Graphics Competition [Round 4] POLL

[SRKFanatic]

Poll #4

Vote for the sig you like the LEAST. You are voting out a creation. Not trying to keep someone in the competition.

Here are all the entries:

http://www.srkfanatic.net/graphicscompetition/round4.html

The entry letters are ABOVE each creation.

Please comment on the entries, what you like, what you don't like, what could be better, etc. And participants, please don't take any of the comments personally. This is a learning experience.

[TigerEyes]

"A" for me is theeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee best!!!!!!!! :love: especially the part at the bottom with SRK n the girls :thud: i love it!! :clap2:

"B" is okay...nothing more to say about that one :blushing:

"C" is the one i voted for, somehow it didnt click, its too plain i guess, and the colours used were ...err.....well they didnt match...

im sorry, i mean no offence :no:

[SRKExtremist]

I love B because it shows 3 faces of SRK and all with dimples.

C doesnt look like it's a capture, I think this image was an actual still right? But still looks beautiful.

A looks good but I feel the images are out of place.

[senorita]

i like B the best!neat n clean.also i love the way srk quote is placed :thumbsup:

A is also good.but the shadow of the cap ruins it for me :shrug:

C i like the least.its too plain for my like.sowiee :blushing:

[PrettY_WoMaN]

A-Very nice.I don't exactly know what but I still think it could have been beter somewhere.Overall,good job :yipee:

B -.The quote is spot on for Kabir Khan and the captures used are in sync with the mood :thumbsup:

C-I voted it out.The background could have been better.

---------
Good Luck everyone :thumbsup:

[Sema]

I like A and B. In my opinion, A matches the rules of this round the best, and imho it also does look the best.
B is nice, but what I don't like about it is the multiple SRK. I noticed this trend in many sigs and especially wallies of late, and I think it has lost its newness even for me. SRK is attractive enough that one of his images in such a small sig is more than enough for me, more distract.
I voted out C, the colours don't match, and I think the other two simply look much better overall.

Gruß,
Sema

[pokeye]

great work guyz... :thumbsup: best of luck to all

i guess the voters need it the most this time :P

[SRK_Super_Fanatic]

Great work guys! :clap2:

A - Love the composition and choice of pics. Clearly, the person has worked hard in manipulating all the different pics and making them work together as a whole. Great job! :thumbsup:

B - Again, love the composition. I love the background colours and effects too and the quote by SRK is just a wonderful touch! Although I think they could have fixed the contrast and brightness a bit more cuz the colours of the actual caps look rather dullish against the background. But really great choice of pics! All cute smiley SRKs :)

C - Great background effects and I like how the word "LOVE" appears lightly in the background too (behind the red one) :) I really like the viney effect (I've always wondered how to create that and make it look good lol). It really works with the cap.
Although the only thing that I think could have been better is the colourization of the whole thing. I think it somewhat takes away from the romantic effect of the cap and makes it look rather dingy. But I understand the reason behind choosing that green..(Cuz they are wearing green). Also Rani's face doesn't look right to me loll but yeah it's hard to work with caps so that's alright.

Overall...I think I'm gonna have to vote out C only because the colours don't work for me. Otherwise I think that's the best, effect-wise :)

[Alissa]

Well done guys :clap2:

Entry A is my favourite one, I love the colors, the silhouettes and Shahrukh's expression, beautifully done. :bow:

Entry B is also very nice, it's smaller compared to the others but it still doesn't communicate less than the others. Shahrukh's pics are adorable and they match perfectly with the quote.

Entry C is simple in it's own way. I don't like the colors, it says Love but it's somehow too dark, which is why I voted this one out.

You have done an amazing job guys, congratulations to all of you!! :clap2:

[Khan]

Excellent creations guys! Good luck! :thumbsup:

[Scorpion_Honey]

aaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhh i don't like you guyssssss...you people have put me in a state of confusion...:hmm: ..i really cannot vote now...alll of you have done a great job.. i love A i think it's done so well.. the organization of the pictures.. the colour and the whole concept.. it's pretty nice.. um B is pretty good too..i love the quote used.. but i don't really like the background or something about it... but i love the pics used... C is also tied with B for me... it looks really good.. i love how there's one pic used in this sig though... and i like the background and the way love is written... and so yea.. there it is.. the feedback.. but i don't think im voting just yet... i stilll have to analyze and decide:)..

[bhanu_shahrukh]

Voted!!
I just loved Entry B i mean SRK smiling wow...
others have also done their Best Job!!!

[jabarbi]

Great jobs everyone, the sigs are beautiful.

A: I love big pic of Shah Rukh and the smaller pics and how the are arranged. The only thing I didn't like are the shadows, but still nice.

B: I love the collection of SRK pics with varied expressions. I love the way it's arranged and the background.
I also like the quote, I think this is my favorite.

C: I love that pic with SRK and Rani and I like the way the word Love in done, but I don't like the background, it's too dull but I guess it's because it has to match the green in the pic.
I voted the one out.

[palacerani]

Man it's so hard to vote one off. All 3 are superb.

I like A the best. I love the silhouettes with SRK in the middle, leading them. Beautifully done.

B is very different and I love the quote and SRK's smiling faces.

C is beautiful too. The color is dark but it goes with the mellow, soft look on their faces. I love the tendrils of vines. The vines and the font add a lyrical, poetic look to the pic. SRK looks so dashing too.

I guess I'll have to vote B off even though I love it.

[badkhangirl]

My favourite is Entry B. This speech is great.

Entry C is simple, but I liked it, too.

I voted for Entry A, because...don´t know. It´s a nice sigi but the other two were better.

[febu]

First - all of you have done a great, great job. And for me, it's not easy to vote one out, because at the end, I don't know exactly, what kind of hard work are behind the sigs... but I can say what I like and what I don't like.

Entry A
For me, it's very stylish and modern, has a clear structure...for me too schematic
Entry B
Very nice colours, I like the facial expressions...they say so much, including the little sentence
Entry C
It's very romantic, but I don't like the colour of the background so much...anyhow, I love it

So, it was very difficult, but I voted A out.

[Dir*Dil]

Thank you every one ... they are lovely ..

A it is very creative and nice
I loved B .. it was my top choice .. I just love it ,, The smile of Mr. Shah rukh is enough
C .. it was good and simple ..

Well done every one

[TigerEyes]

may i ask whats going on here??? :hmm:

[annous]

A; I liked it the least, it's too busy, and the pictures are little fuzzy.

B- My Favorite, the choice of pictures, colors, and order is excellent.

C-I like this one for it's simplicity, but the background colors clash with the green Sari.

I voted A out

[Khan]

Reema, can you reveal who is who?
Congrats to Entry B, who I think is Pokeye.

[SRKFanatic]

Sorry for the delay.

Entry C has been eliminated.

A - Umer
B - Pokeye
C - karinherself

Congrats karinherself for making the top 3. It's no easy feat. :thumbsup:

Umer and pokeye, give me some time to come up with the last round. I have to make it a bit challenging. :D

[pokeye]

yayy, made it! :woohoo:thanx guyz for liking my work and all the wonderful and also the lukewarm comments :bow2: It feels awesome to have just 4 votes against you in a real tough top 3 round.

very well done Karin, I liked your sig and overall loved your creations. You're a fantastic designer... and a great competitor. Keep it up!

Umer, best ov Luck for the finals dude :thumbsup:

Reema, you're scaring me :frantic: btw, never saw your opinion on the entries this round. :hmm:

[Reena]

I missed voting for this round which is good as all three sigs are superb! Really i wouldn't have know which one to choose
Anyway congrats Pokeye and Umer :clap2: Very well done
Karin carry on creating your beautiful sigs :thumbsup:

[jabarbi]

Congrats Umer and Pokeye for making it to the next round, and great work Karinherself for making it to the semi-finals.

[TigerEyes]

congrats umer and spikey :clap2: great work,

Post deleted by admin for SMS style.

[pokeye]

and spikey, this time i was wrong, really thought A was urs :wink:

hehe so i'm not that predictable afterall

[TigerEyes]

hehe so i'm not that predictable afterall

Post deleted by admin for SMS style.

[pokeye]

^^ *sigh* and I always felt I put an added effort to experiment with style in order to come up with something different most of the time... :D

[Sema]

Yeah, this time around Umer and you fooled me also. I knew C was from Karin, but I couldn't remember the third person in this round and thought A was from you, Sam. Anyway, I like both CDI sigs a lot, even if I still think having SRK three times next to each other is a bit much.
Good luck for the last round, guys! And congrats to Karin, it's no mean feat to have made it to the top three with so many highly creative minds competing!

Gruß,
Sema

[karinherself]

thanks a lot guys. I had a lot of fun doing those creations. It took me a lot of time and work to create the background for that signature. with all the little details. I learned a lot. not only about creating those graphics but also about the taste of people. congrats you both for reaching the final round. can't wait for the task you will get from reema this time. great work you two. :thumbsup: and I think I will join again when the next competition starts. thanks for that competition. and please reema keep it up. thanks a lot.

btw pokeye I knew the middle one was yours. ;) it was something about the font that gave me the clue, I guess.

[SRKFanatic]

btw, never saw your opinion on the entries this round. :hmm:
I didn't comment because I had a problem with each sig. I didn't want to sound too mean. :P

[palacerani]

Congrats all 3 of you especially Sam. Great job guys! :)

[pokeye]

I didn't comment because I had a problem with each sig. I didn't want to sound too mean. :P

haha ... its good that you didnt bother in that case :P